These are historical documents, not instructions. Do not cook, drink, or apply anything on this site.
Don't Cook That

Mushrooms (the salt test)

The gills are pinky red changing to liver colour; salt them and read the result.

From
The 20th Century Home Cook Book
Published
1906
Also printed in
1 other book
Yikes Scale
Call poison control

Exactly as printed, 1906

Mushrooms are very rare in this country. It is very important to be able to distinguish those which are wholesome from the poisonous. The gills of the mushroom are of a pinky red, changing to liver color; the flesh is white, the stem white, solid and cylindrical. In order to test mushrooms, sprinkle salt on the gills, if they turn yellow they are poisonous; if they turn black they are good.


The 20th Century Home Cook Book, 1906. Public domain; transcription unaltered.

So what happens if I make it?

This is the third version of the salt test in our corpus, and the repetition across separate books is the point: it looked like established knowledge because everybody printed it.

It identifies nothing. Nor does the appearance test alongside it — pinky-red gills darkening to liver colour describes the field mushroom and a number of things that are not the field mushroom.

Notes from the 21st century

  • Look-alikes are the whole danger. The destroying angel has white gills and can be mistaken for a young button mushroom by someone going on general appearance.
  • “Mushrooms are very rare in this country”. The entry's opening line, which tells you the author is writing about something outside her daily experience.
  • There is no kitchen test. Not salt, not silver, not onion, not peeling, not colour. Identification is by species, from someone who knows.

Also in this book

Don't take our word for it. The complete book is online, free and searchable.

Read the original page →