These are historical documents, not instructions. Do not cook, drink, or apply anything on this site.
Don't Cook That
The list 1851–1919

14 Horrifying Historical Remedies You Should Never Take

What the household kept on the medicine shelf, and what the cookbook told you to do with it.

Cookery, cleaning and home doctoring were bound into the same volume. The chapter on puddings ran a few pages from the chapter on dosing, in the same voice, by the same author, and a reader consulted both the same way.

That is not carelessness. For most households a physician was hours away and had to be paid, and the shelf was the doctor. What follows is what was on it.

Read them, don't make them.

8 of the 14 below contain something now regulated as a poison. Every one of them is quoted from a real book and linked to the scanned original, so you can check us — and then not do it.

  1. 1

    The shelf every household was told to keep.

    The “common, everyday remedies” a home should stock: calomel, paregoric, sulphonal — filed beside the bandages and the bicarbonate. Calomel is mercury chloride. Paregoric is opium. Sulphonal is a hypnotic that was withdrawn once its cumulative poisoning was recognised. None of it was illicit or hard to get. This is a reference book telling a reader what to buy at the druggist, and everything on the list was over the counter.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control Household Discoveries and Mrs. Curtis's Cook Book, 1914 Read the full entry →
  2. 2

    A dosing chart for mercury, in a cookbook.

    One grain twice a day “as an alterative,” four to five as a laxative. The book calls it “a most dangerous medicine” and prints the numbers anyway. Calomel purges by damaging the lining of the gut, and the mercury does not leave when the dose does — it accumulates, and the harm is neurological and permanent. The same drug was sold in teething powders, which is where the childhood mercury poisoning called pink disease came from.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control The 20th Century Home Cook Book, 1906 Read the full entry →
  3. 3

    Mercury, opium and antimony, rolled into one pill.

    Calomel and jalap, ten grains each; opium, a grain and a half; tartar emetic, a grain. “To be taken at once, or divided into pills, if the patient prefer it.” Three poisons with three jobs — the mercury empties you downward, the antimony upward, and the opium is there so you mind none of it. The choice being offered is whether to swallow the mass whole or in pieces.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control Mackenzie's Ten Thousand Receipts, 1867 Read the full entry →
  4. 4

    Dose the child until the medicine comes back out.

    A pint of brandy and an ounce of paregoric — camphorated tincture of opium — a teaspoonful every half hour “until the discharge shows the color of the medicine.” The stopping rule is the alarming part: keep giving a child an opioid until you can see it coming out the other end. That endpoint has no relationship to how much the child has absorbed, and no maximum number of doses appears anywhere in the entry.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control The Dixie Cook-Book, 1883 Read the full entry →
  5. 5

    An ounce of opium tincture, in lemonade.

    “Two ounces of gum arabic, one ounce of paregoric elixir, two ounces of sugar candy, juice of one lemon.” A wineglass morning, noon and night, with no distinction anywhere by age or by weight — a Victorian wineglass held about two fluid ounces, and the same measure is offered to everyone in the house. Opioids genuinely do suppress a cough. The problem was never the mechanism. It was that nobody was counting.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control The Home Cook Book, 1887 Read the full entry →
  6. 6

    Laudanum for a child, every fifteen minutes.

    Equal parts laudanum, rhubarb, double-strength capsicum, camphor and spirits of nitre. “Dose for children, from two to ten drops,” repeated every fifteen minutes until the symptoms stop. That is a fivefold range with no guidance on which end to use, no ceiling, and opium as the active ingredient. Opioids stop breathing before they stop diarrhoea. Cholera kills by dehydration, and clean water with salt and sugar is the treatment.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control The Home Cook Book, 1887 Read the full entry →
  7. 7

    Treat the opium overdose with strychnine.

    The home first-aid table answers a narcotic overdose with “cathartics and stimulants, such as coffee, brandy, and strychnine,” while the patient is walked up and down. The logic is symmetrical and wrong: opium is a depressant, so give a stimulant. Strychnine does stimulate — it is a convulsant, with very little room between a dose that acts and a dose that kills. The brandy quietly adds a second depressant. The walking is the only part that is merely useless.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control Household Discoveries and Mrs. Curtis's Cook Book, 1914 Read the full entry →
  8. 8

    A teaspoonful of alum for a child who cannot breathe.

    “For croup, combine a teaspoonful of powdered alum… with two teaspoonfuls of sugar, and give this promptly.” The sugar is a delivery system — alum is too astringent to swallow otherwise. It works as an emetic, and that is the actual mechanism: the child vomits, and the vomiting was believed to clear the throat. Croup is a viral swelling of the airway, and inducing vomiting in someone already struggling to breathe risks them inhaling it.

    ☠️ Poison Pantry Big yikes Meals Medicinal, 1905 Read the full entry →
  9. 9

    Make the choking person vomit.

    “If you can get it neither up nor down, place two grains of tartar emetic in the patient's mouth.” As it dissolves it will make him “excessively sick,” and the obstruction may shift. Tartar emetic is an antimony salt and a violent emetic, so the instruction is to induce vomiting in a person who cannot protect their own airway. The reasoning is at least visible — retching might dislodge it — and it is applied in the worst possible way.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Yikes Mackenzie's Ten Thousand Receipts, 1867 Read the full entry →
  10. 10

    For rattlesnake bite: a tablespoonful, three times a day, before meals.

    “Take green hoarhound tops and pound them fine; press out the juice” — a tablespoonful “before breakfast, dinner, and just on going to bed.” The schedule is the joke the book does not know it is making. A rattlesnake bite is an emergency measured in minutes; this answers it with a regimen organised around mealtimes. Most bites are survived regardless, which is precisely how a remedy like this earns its reputation.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Yikes The House-Keeper's Guide and Indian Doctor, 1851 Read the full entry →
  11. 11

    Or: burn the wound, then drink to intoxication.

    Twenty-nine years later, a different book, the opposite error. “Apply fire in some form to the wound, thoroughly and immediately,” follow with ammonia, and give whisky “to intoxication.” Cauterising adds a serious burn to an envenomation and does nothing to venom already in the lymphatics. The whisky is worse than useless: alcohol raises the heart rate and opens the vessels, and at that dose it also removes the patient's ability to report how they are doing.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Yikes Buckeye Cookery, 1880 Read the full entry →
  12. 12

    Raw beef and hydrochloric acid, served cold to the sick.

    A pound of chipped raw beef, four ounces of water, four drops of muriatic acid. Twelve hours on ice, strained, served cold. It is warmed in a bain-marie for an hour on the way, which sounds like cooking and is not — the temperature never comes near anything that would make raw beef safe. The acid is a digestion theory: pre-digest the meat outside the body so an invalid can absorb it. It was fed to the people least able to survive it.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Call poison control Cooking in Old Créole Days, 1904 Read the full entry →
  13. 13

    A full purgative dose, hidden in a soft drink.

    Soda water, two tablespoonfuls of sarsaparilla syrup, then two tablespoonfuls of castor oil, filled from the syphon, “and drink at once.” That is about 30 ml — a full adult dose, and ricinoleic acid acts directly on the intestinal wall. The disguise is the entire design: the formula exists to get the dose past somebody who would not otherwise swallow it, at a counter where it looks like a treat. Soda fountains were attached to drugstores, and this is the seam showing.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Yikes On Uncle Sam's Water Wagon, 1919 Read the full entry →
  14. 14

    And one that could not possibly hurt you.

    “A half-teaspoonful of ARM & HAMMER BRAND BICARBONATE OF SODA in a glass of water… will often ward off a cold in its early stages.” It is a brand pamphlet, and the claim is advertising: bicarbonate does nothing to a cold, which resolves on its own — which is exactly why the claim was so safe to make. After thirteen entries of mercury, opium and antimony, being sold something useless feels almost like being let off.

    💊 Doctor's Orders Yikes Book of Valuable Recipes, 1915 Read the full entry →

Every one of these is a household reference book rather than a medical text — sold to families, kept in kitchens, and consulted at three in the morning by somebody who had no other option. That is worth holding on to while reading them. They were not being reckless. They were being resourceful, with what they had and what was then known.

There are 130 more where these came from. Every one quoted in full, with the book it was printed in.

Browse all 144 →