These are historical documents, not instructions. Do not cook, drink, or apply anything on this site.
Don't Cook That

Yellow Sauce

Two eggs, raw, beaten with sugar and poured over the pudding.

From
The Catskill Cook Book
Published
1911
Yikes Scale
Yikes

Exactly as printed, 1911

Beat yolks of two eggs until light and creamy, add half cup powdered sugar gradually, and continue beating. Beat whites of two eggs until stiff and dry, add another half-cup of sugar and continue beating. Combine mixtures and add one teaspoon vanilla or the same of other flavoring.

— Miss F. Victoria Myers


The Catskill Cook Book, 1911. Public domain; transcription unaltered.

So what happens if I make it?

Nothing here heats the egg. There is no custard stage, no bain-marie and no hot syrup poured onto the whites — the sugar and the beating change the texture and nothing else.

The hot pudding underneath is not a cooking step. By the time the sauce reaches the table it has warmed a little, which is the least useful temperature range there is.

Notes from the 21st century

  • An Italian meringue fixes the whites. Hot sugar syrup at 240°F poured into the beating whites cooks them, and gives a better texture besides.
  • A stirred custard fixes the yolks. Take them to about 175°F over gentle heat. That is a proper crème anglaise, which is what this sauce is imitating.
  • Pudding sauces were often raw. Hard sauce, foamy sauce, this one. A whole family of them relied on the pudding's heat to do work it cannot do.

Don't take our word for it. The complete book is online, free and searchable.

Read the original page →