These are historical documents, not instructions. Do not cook, drink, or apply anything on this site.
Don't Cook That

Adulteration (the trade's defense)

The grocery trade, in 1911, explaining that at least half the accusations are unfounded.

From
The Grocer's Encyclopedia
Published
1911
Yikes Scale
Odd

Exactly as printed, 1911

The cry of adulteration goes to great extremes, the desire to appear critical and to be considered a good judge gives rise to much of it, and no sensible dealer will encourage it. Indeed, an honest and intelligent investigation nearly always proves that at least half the accusations are unfounded.

It should also be remembered that there are many food items which are not desirable when absolutely pure--mustard is "adulterated" by nearly every large manufacturer by the addition of flour, because it is too pungent in its natural state; such "adulteration" is not only harmless but may be defended as perfectly proper and justifiable.

Again, many of the statements with regard to adulteration are rendered alarming by the misuse of chemical terms. To tell the average consumer that a table syrup is made of "glucose" is to state a mystery; to say that it is made of "starch treated with hydrochloric or muriatic acid" would cause alarm--yet the final result is a thoroughly wholesome product whose principal constituents are "sugars" identical with, or closely allied to, those into which the sucrose of flowers is converted by bees in the manufacture of honey, and all starchy food is converted by the human stomach in the ordinary process of digestion.


The Grocer's Encyclopedia, 1911. Public domain; transcription unaltered.

So what happens if I make it?

Nothing here will hurt you. It is included because it is the other side of every adulteration recipe on this site, written in the same decade, by people with an interest.

And the narrow point is not even wrong. Pure mustard flour is ferociously hot and genuinely was cut for the table. The move is using that reasonable case to wave off the rest.

Notes from the 21st century

  • The timing matters. The US Pure Food and Drug Act passed in 1906. This is a trade encyclopedia five years later, still arguing the point.
  • Some of what it defends is real. Blending, standardising and diluting are ordinary food manufacture. The word covers both that and sugar of lead in wine.
  • Read it against the French Wine manual. That book gives working directions for lead-fined liquor. Both were on the same shelf, in the same trade, at the same time.

Also in this book

  • Borated Fish — The entire dictionary entry, in full: fish preserved by boracic acid, largely imported from Norway.

Don't take our word for it. The complete book is online, free and searchable.

Read the original page →